Choke plates on old Hondas have been a sore spot for a long time because of the tiny torsion springs that tend to break. When they do, they get sucked into the air stream feeding the engine and can lead to catastrophic engine failure. Lots of people have posted their method for repair, but I think
@Dunk had the most helpful idea.
Click HERE to go to his thread. He did a nice repair on a choke plate for his CB360, and described the wire he used; showed the spring he made; explained how he removed and replaced the pivot pin; but left out one part that drove me crazy for a while. He did not show exactly
how he wound his spring. I even sent him a PM to ask, but I don't believe he saw it. So, Dunk, if you see this, thanks for the info you shared, but I am still curious as to your method.
I thought about this for way too long, but I finally went ahead and ordered some
music wire. I knew about piano wire, but I had never heard of winding springs from this stuff before I read Dunk's thread. I got mine from McMaster-Carr:
I figured that 12" lengths ought to be plenty long enough for the tiny springs I needed to make, and 100 pieces ought to give me enough to practice and make as many mistakes as necessary to figure it out (plus that is the minimum order quantity).
After doing some measuring, I came up with the following:
- Pivot rod = 1.5mm diameter, or .060"
- Outside of coil = 3.0mm diameter, or .118"
- Wire = 3.5mm diameter, or .014"
- Number of coils on the old spring = 10
- Leg length on old spring = 5mm, or .190"
The legs need to be tangential to the body of the spring, not axial, radial, or radial-over center. If you don't know the meaning of tangential, you could watch this short video, or just look at the spring pictured on the left here:
The reason this is important is that we need some way to hold the first leg of the spring as we wind the coils that will keep the first leg tangent to the coil. We can't just have a mandrel with a hole through the middle, where we could poke the wire through the hole and start winding the wire. That would make the leg radial to the coil, which wouldn't fit the choke plate correctly.
I watched this next guy's video and got an idea that I tried, but it wound up as a fail. You might want to watch it anyway, but I recommend watching it on double speed.
This is what I wound up trying to do after watching his video. I dug a couple of metal bits out of my scrap bin, a piece of 1" square aluminum bar stock and a piece of 1"x1/8" steel strip.
I drilled a 1/16" hole in the center of the end of the aluminum bar, and through the flat side of the steel strip. Then I reversed the drill bit in the chuck so the smooth end was down, still centered over the hole in the aluminum bar.
I also drilled and tapped a hole in the steel strip for a small bolt with a washer to grip the end of the music wire. Ignore those other extraneous holes -- remember, I fished this out of the scrap bin,
With the small bolt run in and snugged down, I flipped the strip over and cut/filed the end of the bolt smooth to the surface:
The washer was necessary to grip the small diameter wire to the steel strip. I also had to bend a hook in the wire and place it under the washer. Otherwise, the wire kept slipping out during the winding process.
Next, with the wire captured under the washer, I put the steel strip on top of the aluminum bar and lowered the drill such that the smooth end of the bit went through the the steel strip and into the aluminum. I locked the quill of the drill in this position.
I gripped the other end of the wire with some small vise grips:
Then I got my wife to hold the vise grips and pull lightly on the wire as I held the steel strip flat against the aluminum bar and started winding it around the drill bit.
(Here, the wire isn't quite taut because I had to use one hand for the camera.)
With the wire positioned as shown, the spring would be wound in the proper direction, rotating the steel strip clockwise around the drill bit. The difficult part here is that you have to pass under the long end of the wire each time around. If you let go of the steel strip, the spring wants to unwind, messing up the shape of the coils.
I really thought this would work, and it almost did. After a half dozen attempts that ended with the wire pulled loose or broken after only a few turns, I managed to make one spring. It was a rough first attempt, but was not usable:
As you can see, the coils were too loosely wound next to each other, and the spring was too wide to fit properly. In the above picture, the leg pointing to the right needs to nestle down into the recessed area in the choke plate between the two screw holes. Otherwise, when installed onto the choke pivot bar, the spring leg would be damaged or cut.
Although this attempt failed, the relief door did spring properly, so I figured I was on the right track. I just needed to improve the spring winding process.
Next up: a better method.